Menupickcom lists publicly available information. We are not affiliated with the restaurants shown. How we source and check listings

Menupickcom

Papa Leo's Pizzeria menu

18 dishes across 5 sections $10 to $20 Pizza Restaurant

Prices transcribed from the printed menu, last checked

Menu Papa Leo's Pizzeria photo menu 1
Photographed in store, August 2026. See all 4 pages

Photos of the printed menu

Photographed in store in August 2026. The dish list below covers everything we could read clearly; the full card has more.

Hot Subs 26 dishes

  • Stinger Sub (8") $14.49

    Can't decide between steak and chicken finger? Try them both!

  • Steak & Cheese Sub (12") $16.99

  • Chicken Finger Sub (8") $13.99

  • Cheeseburger Sub (12") $16.99

  • Chicken Club Sub (12") $16.99

  • Bacon Cheeseburger Sub (8") $14.49

  • Chicken Finger Sub (12") $16.99

  • Rodeo BBQ Cheeseburger (8") $13.99

    Burger patties, onion rings, honey BBQ sauce... Yee haw!

  • Grilled Chicken Sub (12") $16.99

  • Deluxe Sub (8") $14.49

    Get the best of both worlds with this Italian sausage and steak sub!

  • Cheeseburger Sub (8") $13.99

  • Royal Sub (12") $17.49

    Fried capicola and Italian sausage.

  • Deluxe Sub (12") $17.49

    Get the best of both worlds with this Italian sausage and steak sub!

  • Stinger Sub (12") $17.49

    Can't decide between steak and chicken finger? Try them both!

  • B.L.T. Sub (12") $16.99

    Please specify lettuce, tomato, and onion.

  • Royal Sub (8") $14.49

    Fried capicola and Italian sausage.

  • Steak & Cheese Sub (8") $13.99

  • Grilled Chicken Sub (8") $13.99

  • Sausage Sub (12") $16.99

  • Rodeo BBQ Cheeseburger (12") $16.99

    Burger patties, onion rings, honey BBQ sauce... Yee haw!

  • B.L.T. Sub (8") $13.99

    Please specify lettuce, tomato, and onion.

  • Bacon Cheeseburger Sub (12") $17.49

  • Sausage Sub (8") $13.99

  • Chicken Club Sub (8") $13.99

  • Cheesesteak Hoagie (8") $13.99

    Our delicious steak with fried green peppers, fried mushrooms, and fried onion. #1 ordered sub!

  • Cheesesteak Hoagie (12") $16.99

    Our delicious steak with fried green peppers, fried mushrooms, and fried onion. #1 ordered sub!

Traditional Pizza 6 dishes

  • 2 Slices & Pop $9.29

  • 1/2 Tray Pizza $24.99

    15 slice half-tray pizza.

  • Med Pizza $16.99

    12" 6 slice pie.

  • Party Pizza $37.99

    30 slice tray (2x half trays).

  • Slice $2.99

  • X-Large $20.99

    16" 8 slice pie.

Extras 21 dishes

  • Tartar Sauce $1.49

  • Pizza Sauce $1.49

  • Mild Sauce $1.49

    Mild.

  • Honey BBQ Sauce $1.49

  • Cocktail Sauce $1.49

  • Medium Sauce $1.49

    Medium.

  • Salsa $1.49

  • Sweet Chili Sauce $1.79

  • Fried Dough Sauce $1.79

  • Butter Garlic $1.49

  • Boom Boom Sauce $1.49

  • Ranch $1.49

  • Hot Sauce $1.49

  • BBQ Sauce $1.89

  • Honey Mustard Sauce $1.49

  • Garlic Parm Sauce $1.49

  • Honey Garlic Sauce $1.49

  • Blue Cheese $1.49

  • Teriyaki Sauce $1.79

  • Coleslaw $2.99

  • Scooter Sauce $1.99

Burgers 5 dishes

  • Mushroom Swiss Burger $14.99

    Angus burger served with sautéed mushrooms covered in melted Swiss cheese on our fresh Costanzo's kaiser rolls. Served with fries.

  • Hamburger $11.99

    Keeping it simple? Can't go wrong with our mouthwatering hamburgers. Served with fries.

  • Pickle Ranch Burger $13.99

    Angus burger served with pickle slices and deep-fried pickle chips coated in ranch dressing. So good! Served with fries.

  • Cheeseburger $12.99

    Your standard delicious cheeseburger with melted white American. Served with fries.

  • Rodeo Burger $15.99

    Let's take it out west. Angus burger served with 2 onion rings and doused in mouth watering tangy honey BBQ sauce. So good! Served with fries.

Specialty Pizza 39 dishes

  • Chicken Alfredo Pizza (1/2 Tray) $31.99

    Our creamy Alfredo sauce, mouthwatering grilled chicken topped with mozzarella.

  • Dill Pickle Pizza (XL) $23.99

    White base pizza, with mozzarella and pickle slices. Dusted with dillweed, its the new craze!

  • Dill Pickle Pizza (Medium) $20.99

    White base pizza, with mozzarella and pickle slices. Dusted with dillweed, its the new craze!

  • Chicken Finger Pizza (Medium) $23.99

    Blue cheese base, with medium sauce fingers. Its a buffalo thing!

  • Chicken Cordon Blue (XL) $27.99

    Ranch base with chicken, ham, Swiss, Cheddar and mozzarella? What could go wrong?

  • Chicken Alfredo Pizza (Medium) $24.99

    Our creamy Alfredo sauce, mouthwatering grilled chicken topped with mozzarella.

  • Chicken Parmesan Pizza (Medium) $22.99

    Red sauce base with fingers and mozzarella.

  • Philly Cheesesteak Pizza (Medium) $24.99

    White base pizza, with American cheese, fried peppers, fried mushrooms, and fried onions come standard. Fan favorite!

  • Chicken Alfredo Pizza (XL) $29.99

    Our creamy Alfredo sauce, mouthwatering grilled chicken topped with mozzarella.

  • Stinger Pizza (XL) $30.99

    Cant decide between steak and chicken? Try both! Blue cheese base, medium fingers.

  • Chicken Cordon Blue (1/2 Tray) $29.99

    Ranch base with chicken, ham, Swiss, Cheddar and mozzarella? What could go wrong?

  • Hawaiian Pizza (XL) $27.99

    Ham and pineapple on a red base pizza, just to show everyone pineapple does belong on pizza!

  • Meat Lover's Pizza (Medium) $24.99

    Red base with pepperoni, sausage, ham, and bacon!

  • Philly Cheesesteak Pizza (XL) $29.99

    White base pizza, with American cheese, fried peppers, fried mushrooms, and fried onions come standard. Fan favorite!

  • "The Beast" (1/2 Tray) $35.99

    This beast has pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, mushroom, onion and an extra drizzle of mozzarella.

  • Chicken Parmesan Pizza (1/2 Tray) $29.99

    Red sauce base with fingers and mozzarella.

  • Chicken Finger Pizza (XL) $29.99

    Blue cheese base, with medium sauce fingers. Its a buffalo thing!

  • Chicken Cordon Blue (Medium) $24.99

    Ranch base with chicken, ham, Swiss, Cheddar and mozzarella? What could go wrong?

  • Meatball Parm Pizza (XL) $28.99

    Our flavorful meatballs on a red base with crushed red pepper and mozzarella!

  • Meatball Parm Pizza (1/2 Tray) $30.99

    Our flavorful meatballs on a red base with crushed red pepper and mozzarella!

  • Hawaiian Pizza (Medium) $22.99

    Ham and pineapple on a red base pizza, just to show everyone pineapple does belong on pizza!

  • Dill Pickle Pizza (1/2 Tray) $27.99

    White base pizza, with mozzarella and pickle slices. Dusted with dillweed, its the new craze!

  • Stinger Pizza (Medium) $26.99

    Cant decide between steak and chicken? Try both! Blue cheese base, medium fingers.

  • White Pizza (XL) $27.99

    White base pizza with tomato and onions.

  • Veggie Pizza (XL) $26.99

    Red base pizza with tomato, onion, mushroom, black & green olives, topped with mozzarella.

  • Philly Cheesesteak Pizza (1/2 Tray) $31.99

    White base pizza, with American cheese, fried peppers, fried mushrooms, and fried onions come standard. Fan favorite!

  • Veggie Pizza (1/2 Tray) $29.99

    Red base pizza with tomato, onion, mushroom, black & green olives, topped with mozzarella.

  • Hawaiian Pizza (1/2 Tray) $29.99

    Ham and pineapple on a red base pizza, just to show everyone pineapple does belong on pizza!

  • White Pizza (1/2 Tray) $29.99

    White base pizza with tomato and onions.

  • Meat Lover's Pizza (XL) $29.99

    Red base with pepperoni, sausage, ham, and bacon!

  • Chicken Finger Pizza (1/2 Tray) $33.99

    Blue cheese base, with medium sauce fingers. Its a buffalo thing!

  • White Pizza (Medium) $22.99

    White base pizza with tomato and onions.

  • Stinger Pizza (1/2 Tray) $33.99

    Cant decide between steak and chicken? Try both! Blue cheese base, medium fingers.

  • Meatball Parm Pizza (Medium) $23.99

    Our flavorful meatballs on a red base with crushed red pepper and mozzarella!

  • "The Beast" (Medium) $26.99

    This beast has pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, mushroom, onion and an extra drizzle of mozzarella.

  • Meat Lover's Pizza (1/2 Tray) $33.99

    Red base with pepperoni, sausage, ham, and bacon!

  • Chicken Parmesan Pizza (XL) $26.99

    Red sauce base with fingers and mozzarella.

  • Veggie Pizza (Medium) $21.99

    Red base pizza with tomato, onion, mushroom, black & green olives, topped with mozzarella.

  • "The Beast" (XL) $32.99

    This beast has pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, mushroom, onion and an extra drizzle of mozzarella.

Monthly Specials 3 dishes

  • XL Chicken Finger $20.99

    Blue cheese base, with medium sauce fingers. Its a Buffalo thing!

  • Topping Galore $19.99

  • 12" Turkey Sub $9.99

Breadsticks 4 dishes

  • Fried Dough Sticks (12) $11.99

    Served with 2 sides of dessert sauce.

  • Breadsticks (6) $6.99

    Served with 1 side of marinara.

  • Fried Dough Sticks (6) $8.99

    Served with 1 dessert sauce.

  • Breadsticks (12) $10.99

    Served with 2 sides of marinara.

Oven-Baked Subs 6 dishes

  • Meatball Parmesan Sub (12”) $16.99

    Red sauce and meatballs, topped with mozzarella and baked golden.

  • Chicken Parmesan Sub (12”) $16.99

    Red sauce and fingers, topped with mozzarella and baked golden.

  • Pizza Sub (12") $16.99

  • Tuna Melt Sub (12”) $16.99

    Tuna sub, but oven-baked!

  • Pizza Sub (8") $13.99

  • Baked Cheese Sub (12”) $15.99

    Oven-baked sub with multiple cheeses of your choice!

Munchies 11 dishes

  • Jalapeño Poppers $9.99

    Served with sour cream.

  • Cheddar Bacon Fries $8.99

    Served with ranch dressing.

  • Deep-Fried Mushrooms $9.49

    Served with blue cheese.

  • Cajun French Fries $5.99

    Served with ranch dressing.

  • French Fries $4.99

    Served with ketchup.

  • Buffalo Fries $6.99

    French fries tossed in hot sauce, served with blue cheese.

  • Mozzarella Stix $9.99

    Served with marinara sauce.

  • Pizza Logs $10.99

    Served with marinara sauce.

  • Onion Rings $7.49

    Served with boom boom sauce.

  • Chips $1.49

  • Fried Pickles $8.49

    Served with ranch.

Garlic Bread 4 dishes

  • Garlic Bread $8.99

    Served with marinara.

  • Garlic Bread With Cheese $9.99

    Served with marinara.

  • Garlic Bread With Cheese & Sausage $12.99

    Served with marinara.

  • Garlic Bread With Jalapeño & Bacon $12.99

    Served with marinara.

Burritos 9 dishes

  • Philly Cheesesteak Burrito $12.99

    Steak, fried mushroom, fried onion, fried green peppers.

  • Beef Burrito $11.99

  • Chicken Parm Burrito $11.99

  • Steak Burrito $11.99

  • Chicken Finger Burrito $11.99

  • Grilled Chicken Burrito $11.99

  • Stinger Burrito $12.99

    Steak and fingers with your choice of sauce.

  • Chicken Fajita Burrito $11.99

    Comes with fried onions and green peppers.

  • Veggie Burrito $11.99

Jumbo Buffalo Wings 5 dishes

  • 20 Wings $29.99

  • 50 Wings $59.99

  • 30 Wings $39.99

  • 10 Wings $18.99

  • 80 Wings $99.99

Chicken Fingers 2 dishes

  • Finger Dinner (5) $19.99

    5 fingers, your choice of sauce. Served with fries and blue cheese.

  • Family Feast (10) $29.99

    10 fingers, your choice of sauce. Served with fries and blue cheese.

Salads 6 dishes

  • Julienne Salad $14.99

    Lettuce, tomato, onion, fresh mozzarella, freshly sliced ham and turkey.

  • Grilled Chicken Salad $14.99

    Lettuce, tomato, onion, mozzarella cheese, juicy grilled strips of chicken breast.

  • Taco Salad $14.99

    Lettuce, tomato, onion, hot peppers, black olives, with fresh mozzarella and hot taco meat, served with sour cream and med sauce on the side.

  • Antipasto $14.99

    Lettuce, tomato, onion, sliced hot peppers, sliced black olives, fresh mozzarella cheese, freshly sliced salami and pepperoni.

  • Buffalo Chicken Salad $14.99

    Lettuce, tomato, onions, mozzarella cheese, chicken fingers shook in sauce of your choice.

  • Garden Salad $9.99

    Lettuce, sliced tomatoes, diced onion, topped with fresh mozzarella.

Beverages 4 dishes

  • 20oz Soda $2.99

  • Energy Drink $3.99

  • 2-Liter Soda $3.59

  • Bottled Water $2.49

Seafood 2 dishes

  • Fish Fry $19.99

    Our 16 oz battered haddock with tartar, served with fries and coleslaw.

  • Breaded Shrimp $12.99

    Our honey-battered shrimp, served with cocktail sauce and served with fries.

Quesadillas 4 dishes

  • Grilled Chicken Quesadilla $14.99

    Served with salsa and sour cream. Comes with light onion.

  • Steak Quesadilla $14.99

    Served with salsa and sour cream. Comes with light onion.

  • Beef Quesadilla $14.99

    Served with salsa and sour cream. Comes with light onion.

  • Cheese Quesadilla $12.99

    Served with salsa and sour cream. Comes with light onion.

Deli Subs 20 dishes

  • Salami Sub (8") $12.99

  • Veggie Sub (12") $14.99

    Your choice of lettuce, tomato, and onion. Comes with black and green olives as well.

  • The Alexander (12") $15.99

    Capicola and turkey, with a light drizzle of hot sauce.

  • Capicola Sub (8") $12.99

  • Ham & Turkey Sub (12") $15.99

  • Capicola Sub (12") $15.99

  • Tuna Sub (8") $12.99

  • Ham Sub (8") $12.99

  • Bologna Sub (8") $12.99

  • Ham & Turkey Sub (8") $12.99

  • Ham Sub (12") $15.99

  • Bologna Sub (12") $15.99

  • Turkey Club Sub (8") $13.49

  • Veggie Sub (8") $11.99

    Your choice of lettuce, tomato, and onion. Comes with black and green olives as well.

  • Turkey Club Sub (12") $16.49

  • Salami Sub (12") $15.99

  • Assorted Sub (8") $12.99

    Capicola, bologna, and salami.

  • The Alexander (8") $12.99

    Capicola and turkey, with a light drizzle of hot sauce.

  • Assorted Sub (12") $15.99

    Capicola, bologna, and salami.

  • Tuna Sub (12") $15.99

About these prices

Restaurants change prices without notice, and a menu photographed in August may already be out of date. Treat these figures as a guide, not a quote. If you spot a difference, tell us and we will re-check it.

Other menus in Niagara Falls

Prices transcribed the same way, each with the date last checked.

All Niagara Falls listings
Call Menu Directions